Tragedy in Mariana: BHP's fault will be judged in October 2024

Initially, the hearings were scheduled for April 2024. But this Friday (14), the judges partially granted the mining company's request for postponement, which defended the holding of the hearing only in 2025. BHP Billiton wanted more time to allow the manifestation of the OK in the process, among other reasons. The defense of those affected spoke out against the postponement.

British court postpones trial against BHP for environmental disaster in Mariana

The British court postponed this Friday (12) for six months (from April 2024 to October 2024), the beginning of a process in London in which 720 thousand victims demand 45 billion dollars (223,6 billion reais, at the current price) of the mining company BHP due to the collapse of a dam in Mariana, Minas Gerais, in 2015.

BHP Billiton and Vale are the shareholders of the mining company Samarko, responsible for the dam that failed in Mariana in 2015. In the episode, the tailings avalanche reached the Rio Doce basin, impacting dozens of municipalities in Minas Gerais and Espírito Santo. Nineteen people died.

In the action filed in the United Kingdom, Those affected maintain that there is not enough justice being done in Brazil. The Pogust Goodhead office represents thousands of people affected, as well as companies, municipalities and religious institutions. In March, 500 new authors joined the process. In this way, there are now 700 thousand people and entities represented. The defense of those affected states that the process costs around R$230 billion.

BHP Billiton's defense disputes the duplication of trials in both countries and claims to trust in the reparation of damages carried out by the Renova Foundation, under the supervision of Brazilian courts. The Renova Foundation was created in 2016 to manage all reparatory actions provided for in an agreement signed between the mining companies, the Union and the governments of Minas Gerais and Espírito Santo.

postponement

Tom Goodhead, one of the partners at Pogust Goodhead, spoke out in a note following the new decision, scheduling the judgment on BHP's liability for October 2024. “BHP speaks of injustice without thinking about the real victims, who suffer from the catastrophic devastation of their families, homes and land, simply because BHP values ​​profit above people’s lives.” According to the law firm, maintaining the trial in 2024 is a victory for those affected. They informed that the deadline for those affected to send information ends on May 21st.

In turn, BHP considered the decision positive. “Such postponement is necessary to ensure that the parties have sufficient time to prepare and complete the numerous procedural steps necessary for the hearing.” According to the mining company, the British court agreed to discuss in the trial whether those affected who signed compensation agreements in Brazil would be entitled to compensation for damages in the United Kingdom. The mining company also says that the statute of limitations for the case will be debated. The hearings that will take place in October 2024 are expected to last 11 weeks. 

(With Brazil Agency)

Read also

Brazil's worst environmental tragedy will be tried in British court

Mariana's disaster will end up in the English court! The United Kingdom Court will examine, from 2024, a collective action that claims billions of pounds from the Australian mining company BHP for its responsibility in the collapse of the Samarco dam, in Mariana/MG, which left 19 dead in 2015 — reported sources linked to the process this Thursday (22).

In Brazil, 4 million were affected by dam collapses in the last 80 years, says Fiocruz

More than 4 million people have been affected by construction and dam failures in Brazil over the last 80 years. This number was released in the study “Health, water, energy, environment and work: weaving knowledge in the promotion of sustainable and healthy territories”, carried out by the Osvaldo Cruz Foundation (Fiocruz), in partnership with the Movement of People Affected by Dams (MAB).

Receive news and newsletters do Curto News by Telegram e WhatsApp.